The main challenges in designing, prioritizing, and implementing Nature‑based Solutions for flood risk mitigation?

The main challenges in designing, prioritizing, and implementing Nature‑based Solutions for flood risk mitigation?

by sitaram sharnangat -
Number of replies: 1

Hello everyone. This is Sitaram Sharnangat from India. I am in the conservation sector for last 33 years mostly working in watershed development, Terrestrial and Freshwater ecosystem protection and restoration. I have completed PhD in Rural Development from Tata Institute of Social Sciences , India. I also completed Master of Social Work, Bachelor of Journalism and Diploma in Civil Engineering. 

I worked mostly in India so far, where the concept of NBS is comparatively new. People mostly know and believe grey infrastructure like water harvesting structure. people think big dam stores flood water temporary and reduces flood risk. So challenges starts from top level leadership where political decisions are to be taken to incorporate NBS for flood risk mitigation. 

Because of the impact of climate change, the  rainfall patterns are changing and become very unpredictable in India, river basins are very large with variable rainfall, mixed geology with 92% hard rock, mixed land use and fragmented land ownership. 

Presence  of invasive species, and lack of coordination between different stakeholders like water resource, Ground water survey and authority, Agriculture, Forest, and Panchayat Raj department of government , Partner, Research institute is truly difficult. It become difficult to design technically sound NBS in such situation which may be accepted by respective stakeholders. Everyone have their own technical criteria.

In reply to sitaram sharnangat

Re: The main challenges in designing, prioritizing, and implementing Nature‑based Solutions for flood risk mitigation?

by Abdul-roqeeb Solotan -
As a fresh Nigerian graduate navigating this field, I see the main barrier to Nature-based Solutions as a clash between natural timelines and urban reality: concrete gets quick political approval, while restoring mangrove buffers in Lekki or building bioswales may take years to mature and compete with high-value real estate. 
Additionally, standard engineering and economic models favor gray infrastructure because they know how to price concrete, but don't know how to value the long-term flood defense and social benefits that healthy ecosystems provide to vulnerable coastal communities.